Thursday, June 23, 2011

Default Explained

Readers Question: What is “the default”, which BBC likes to talk about, but never explains?

On the BBC, there is much coverage of the current issue of 'debt default'. This refers to government debt and the possibility the government may not be able to pay back the debts it owes.

It's the same principle as an individual borrowing a significant amount of money, but then being unable to pay back the debt. Therefore they declare bankruptcy and don't pay their loans back.

In recent years, Governments have spent more than they receive in tax. When a government spends more than it receives in tax, they meet this shortfall by borrowing from the private sector. They borrow money by selling bonds. These bonds are bought by private investors, banks and investment trusts.

They lend the government money because the government pay interest on bonds. Government bonds are usually seen as a secure way to invest money and get interest in return.



Government budget deficits have increased after recession of 2007.

However, some countries like Greece and Ireland have seen a very sharp rise in the amount of government debt as a % of GDP. Markets have become worried that they will be unable to pay the interest on these debts and raise enough money to funds its deficit. Greece have tried to reduce its budget deficit by cutting spending, but this has caused a recession and higher unemployment. Markets feel Greece debt is so high they won't be able to bring government debt under control by cutting government spending because even if they cut spending sufficiently, this severely damages the economy.

Default and Interest Rates.

If markets think there is an increased chance of debt default, demand for bonds will fall, leading to higher interest rates. If you look at graph here - Problems in Monetary union, you will see that interest rates on Greek debt has been rising because of fear of debt.

Different Types of Default

To make things a little more confusing, there are different types of default.

Voluntary agreements to extend maturity of loans. This means that holders of government debt agree to extend the length of the loan, rather than getting repaid in 3 years, they get repaid in 5 years. Therefore, the Greek government have longer to pay back their debts. They still have the same amount of debt, just longer to pay them back.

Partial Default / Haircut. Recognising the government cannot pay the full amount of debt back, holders of debt accept a cut in the value of their bonds, e.g. the government pay back just 70% of the value of their bonds. The bond holders may accept this partial repayment because they think it is better to get 70% of the debt than nothing. This is a partial debt default. (It is like a voluntary credit agreement where an individual pays a percentage of debt back rather than declare bankruptcy.

Full Default. A full default would be when the government is bankrupt and can't pay anything at all. Bond holders would lose everything and it would cause a widespread collapse in confidence in European governments ability to repay debt.

In the case of Greece, there is a big debate about whether they should have some kind of default.

Some argue that The debt to GDP ratio is rising so high, the government have no chance of getting this under control. Unfortunately, the Greek governments attempt to reduce their budget deficit (cutting spending and increasing taxes) has pushed the economy into recession, meaning it is harder to raise tax revenues.

Related

Tuesday, June 21, 2011

Will Greece Leave the Euro?

With even intellectual heavyweights like Boris Johnson suggesting Greece should leave the Euro, what are the economic arguments for and against?

I wrote a post here on some of the pros and cons of Greece leaving.

European political leaders seem to discount the possibility of anyone leaving the Euro, yet the head of Germany's prestigious think-tank IFO Institute, Hans-Werner Sinn, predicted that further austerity would be self-defeating and leaving the Euro could be the least bad option.

He said "The policy of forced 'internal devaluation,' deflation and depression could risk driving Greece to the edge of civil war,"

The scope of the problem can be seen in the size of Greece's current account deficit and unemployment

Whether Greece will leave the Euro is very hard to answer. The Greek government and European leaders seem to discount it as an option, but it is hard to see the current approach creating anything other than higher unemployment and greater civil rest. To fight for Euro survival is to fight for the wrong thing. Even if they were to survive this current crisis (and it is hard to see how) the fundamental problems of the Euro remain. It just doesn't work for a country who has different productivity rates, different levels of borrowing and different rates of growth. Also, the Eurozone has shown it is not an optimal currency zone. The unemployed in Greece can't easily move to other areas of the Euro where vacancies are available.

Greece should leave Euro, default on some debt and concentrate on reducing unemployment and creating economic growth.

Thursday, June 16, 2011

Problems of Two Speed Europe

A quick follow up to the problem of unemployment, is the issue of a two speed Europe.

Increasingly there is a divergence between different blocks of countries within the EU. Some economies are showing signs of economic recovery. Others (the likes of Portugal, Ireland, Greece and Spain) are facing an unwelcome combination of stagnant growth, high unemployment, unpopular spending cuts, budget crisis and current account deficits.

unit costs

Another useful graph is the divergence in unit labour costs. Previously if Greece saw rising wages, it would probably lead to a depreciation in Greek currency. But, now that can't happen - leading to the record current account deficit. To deal with uncompetitiveness it is necessary to require a much more painful process of deflation and lower growth.

I've often posted about the inherent problems of a single currency for a two speed Europe (basically you can set monetary policy for two different economic regions)

However, are there any practical problems with the two speed Europe?
  • Fiscal transfers, e.g. from Germany to Greece. This would help solve budget crisis without the need for so much austerity. Fiscal transfers could help reduce geographical unemployment. To some extent the UK did this when unemployment was higher in north of UK than south during the 1980s. However, German tax payers are unlikely to want to fund 'the profligacy of their neighbours' It's one thing to give funds to different regions in your country. But, to give funds to other countries who beat you at football and speak another language is really stretching to the limits of European idealism. - Also there is a danger of moral hazard. If they pay up now, it may keep happening in future.
  • Supply side policies to regain competitiveness. Reducing labour market regulation, reducing power of trades unions, reducing benefits may all help put downward pressure on wages and restore competitiveness. However, it would be wrong to expect too much from supply side reforms. For example, Ireland already has one of lowest levels of labour market regulation in EU. Definitely structural unemployment is a problem for Spain, but it's only part of the problem, there is also the fundamental lack of demand in economy.
More on two speed Europe

Tuesday, June 14, 2011

The Unemployment Problem


The developed world is facing a real and pressing problem - unemployment. But, it seems curiously disinterested in solving it.

In Spain, the unemployment is reaching levels not seen since the Great Depression. Spanish Youth unemployment is approaching 45%. It is unsurprising that this has finally sparked protests.
US unemployment has fallen marginally this year, but at 8.7% job creation is still low on the agenda.

Costs of Unemployment

  1. Economic cost - lost tax revenue (VAT, NI, Income tax), higher spending on benefits (unemployment benefit, housing, income support).
  2. Psychological cost - Unemployed twice as likely to suffer from depression. The World Health Organisation state. “it is almost certain that unemployment damages mental health and probable that it damages physical health.” (pdf on costs of unemployment, TUC)
  3. Decline in motivation. A survey by the Prince’s Trust recorded how young people’s lives
    affected by unemployment:
    • 41% said they found it harder to get out of bed;
    • 29% said they found it harder to leave the house;
    • 28% said they exercised less;
    • 25% said it caused arguments with their parents or other family;
  4. Social inequality. Unemployment creates economic inequality and also feeling of social exclusion. These can be powerful influences which lead to civil and social unrest.
  5. Decline in employability. Workers who are unemployed lose on the job training and are more likely to move into long term unemployment.

Causes of Unemployment

Unemployment is usually caused by a combination of both demand side and supply side. Since 2007, we can see a sharp increase in unemployment, this is a consequence of the great recession and sluggish recovery. It is important to bear in mind that a significant cause of current unemployment is a deficiency of aggregate demand. In this case reducing unemployment benefits and other supply side solutions will not work. The fundamental problem is a lack of AD and economic growth.

In addition to the lack of aggregate demand there is also a problem of structural unemployment. This is due to factors such as:
  • Lack of skills, qualifications, (occupational immobilities)
  • Geographical immobilities (difficult to move around country)
  • Labour Market Rigidities (difficulties to hire and fire workers makes firms more reluctant to hire workers)
See: Causes of unemployment for more details

Are We doing enough about Unemployment?

The problem is that the high level of unemployment is often put far below other economic concerns such as inflation, levels of government borrowing and maintaining exchange rates.

For example, the ECB have responded to temporary inflation by threatening to raise interest rates. The EU periphery is experiencing recession, but there is no plan to tackle the lack of aggregate demand in Greece, Ireland and Spain. To some extent this is a consequence of a single currency and monetary union. (see: problems of Euro)

In the US, the focus is on reducing budget deficit without concentrating on creation of jobs. In the UK, recent austerity measures have threatened to snub out the fragile recovery meaning the unemployment rate could continue to rise.

Europe has a two fold problem. An underlying structural rate of unemployment that occurred even before recession, but also a deficiency of demand stemming from the pursuit of austerity (problem of deficit reduction)

Unemployment in US

US unemployment - inflation

Trade off between inflation and unemployment

Friday, June 3, 2011

Problem of Rising Oil Prices

graph source: Krugman

Readers Question Tonight on NBC news the headliner was more bad economic news. If the economy is so bad, why didn't I get a pay raise in my military retirement or social security this year...i.e., shouldn't the CPI go up if gas prices, etc. are increasing? Thanks.

There are many problems with the US economy at the moment. One issue is the divergence between headline inflation and 'core' inflation.

What this means is that some goods are increasing in price more rapidly than others. Gas (petrol) prices are increasing rapidly, but overall CPI inflation is more muted.

The headline figure includes more volatile prices like food, raw materials and gas prices. As you can see from above graph, sometimes this headline figure is higher than core prices, sometimes it is lower.

Unfortunately, it means that if your pension is linked to inflation, you may feel you are experiencing a decline in living standards because the price of goods you frequently buy are rising faster than the official inflation rate, which is used to decide pension increases.

In the UK, there is a similar situation. Many people are facing a fall in real wages because headline inflation is growing faster than nominal incomes.

It is an unwelcome combination of higher prices, lower growth and a decline in living standards.

Some suggest we should actively target lower inflation through higher interest rates and deflationary fiscal policy. However, others argue this would be an over-reaction. The biggest problem is not a temporary rise in headline inflation, but persistently high unemployment and a stagnating economy.

With rising oil prices you usually have to accept a worse trade off - i.e. higher inflation and / or lower growth. To some extent it is a question of waiting for volatile prices to stop rising.

Should Government Cut Taxes on Petrol (Gas) to Compensate for Rising Prices?

If government did cut taxes on petrol it would have to increases taxes elsewhere. It would merely shift the tax burden rather than make people better off.

However, you could argue higher gas prices do have some external benefits.
  • Provides incentive for firms to develop hybrid cars and alternative forms of energy. In the long term this will make the economy less dependent on the highly volatile oil market.
  • Leads to lower congestion on roads as people have greater incentive to use other forms of transport
  • May encourage better health as people are more likely to walk or cycle rather than rely on cars.
  • Lower emissions help to reduce pollution and increase air quality.

Related

Tuesday, May 31, 2011

Current Account Deficits in the Euro

Some countries in the Euro are experiencing unusually high current account deficits with the rest of the world. One of the main reasons for the size of the current account deficit is that they are unable to allow their currency to depreciate to restore competitiveness.


Source: OECD Statistics

Both Portugal and Greece have a current account deficit of near 10% of GDP - amongst the highest in the developed world.
  • Other countries struggling include Spain. They have seen a fall in the current account deficit from 10% of GDP in 2008 to over 3.5%. But, this is still high.
  • Ireland has also seen a decline in its current account deficit from 5% of GDP to just a small deficit. However, this has been at the cost of a sharp slowdown in consumer spending on imports.
If the UK was in the Euro, we would almost certainly be facing a larger current account deficit.
Since the credit crunch hit the UK, the value of sterling has fallen 20%. To some extent demand for UK exports seem quite inelastic (the fall in price hasn't seen a big increase in demand. see: terms of trade in UK) But, if we had been in the stronger Euro, our exports would be less competitive and imports more attractive.

The Euro isn't the only reason for a Current Account Deficit. Other reasons include
  • Large budget deficits in Greece and Portugal.
  • Property boom in Ireland and Spain which attracted foreign capital flows financing domestic consumption, until it dried up after credit crunch
  • Demographic factors. A young population tends to consume more. Germany has a relatively older population so tends to consume less and save more, contributing to their current account surplus.
  • Labour Costs and Labour Productivity. e.g. Greece experienced unit Labour costs rising by almost double figures in 2007, 2008 and 2010. (Unit Labour Costs OECD)
Netherlanders an overvalued exchange rate exacerbates these fundamental factors causing a current account deficit.

How Else To Reduce Current Account Deficit in the Euro?

The problem facing Portugal, Greece and to a lesser extent Spain is how do they restore competitiveness when they can't rely on depreciation in the exchange rate? They need to rely on:
  • Deflation. Increase taxes and lower spending
  • Wage restraint. Cutting public sector wages and putting downward pressure on private sector wages.
  • Supply side policies to improve competitiveness, e.g. privatisation, more flexible labour markets, deregulation and greater competitiveness.
Supply side policies may help in the long term, but in the short term, restoring competitiveness requires a painful period of deflation to slowly improve competitiveness. Of course, this leads to higher unemployment, slower growth and the protests we are seeing in Greece and Spain.

Spain has an unemployment rate of 21%, which is almost 45% amongst young workers. This shows that there number one priority should be tackling unemployment, yet the constraints of their current economic situation mean they are pursuing deflationary policies, when really the economy needs the opposite.

In a recent post, we looked at how members of the Eurozone were more likely to experience rising bond yields. See: Problem of Euro in Recession

Related

Wednesday, May 11, 2011

Problems of Monetary Union in Recession

bondyields

Since the credit crisis,UK government bond yields have stayed low, despite having similar levels of government borrowing to Spain, Portugal and Ireland.

Why have members of the Euro faced more difficulties in financing debt than the UK?
(It is a similar story for US and Japan where interest rates have stayed low despite high levels of borrowing.)

Essentially members of the Euro need to finance their budget deficit, but they don't control their own monetary policy.

1) Devaluation

Since the credit crisis, the value of sterling has fallen considerably. This helps boost exports and growth. This boost to economic growth helps reassure investors the government will have more ability to pay back debt. The devaluation in sterling also makes sterling assets appear more attractive and so may encourage foreign investors to buy.

2) Bank of England could buy government bonds as last resort.

If the UK has difficulty in financing the deficit, the Bank of England can act as lender of last resort and buy up government bonds. This mechanism gives investors more faith that the UK can remain solvent. There is no danger of a liquidity crisis.

If Spain or Ireland has difficult selling bonds to the private sector, investors will sell Spanish bonds, however, this won't cause a depreciation in the value of the Spanish currency (because there is only the Euro). Therefore unlike the UK, Spanish assets don't become more attractive. Also, Spain will face a stronger currency than is ideal for the state of their economy.

Spain also can't ask the Spanish Central Bank to buy Spanish bonds. In theory the ECB could, but they are reluctant to for various reasons.

The markets know that Spain is more vulnerable - they can't benefit from devaluation and they can't ask their Central Bank to buy bonds. This increases the risk that Spain faces a liquidity crisis (can't raise enough money) Therefore, investors will be quick to move out of Spanish bonds into something more secure. The fear of a liquidity crisis in Eurozone countries means they are much more vulnerable to worries over increase in debt.

Vicious Cycle

As Spain struggle to finance its deficit, it may rely on a bailout from the EU. This provides liquidity but also the ECB impose conditions (punishment). The EU make Spain and Ireland pursue austerity (spending cuts) and accept higher interest rates on bonds. The higher interest rates and spending cuts will lead to lower growth, deflation and higher unemployment. But, this fall in economic growth also leads to lower tax revenues which increases debt and makes Spanish debt more unattractive.

The result is that in a recession, Euro members have become much more vulnerable to problems in the bond market. It also means that their response to a recession needs to focus on deflationary measures (strong exchange rate, higher interest rates and spending cuts). However, this is exactly the wrong response that you need in a recession.

Also, these countries still face an interest rate set by the ECB for the whole Eurozone. The ECB have already indicated that recovery in Germany and France will lead to higher interest rates. But, higher interest rates is not what Ireland needs given they currently have deflation.

UK bonds are relatively more attractive because:
  • The economy has more flexibility to devalue and restore competitiveness
  • They can pursue quantitative easing to boost economic growth
  • The Bank of England has the independence to help buy government securities.
  • There is less risk of deflation and a recession.
  • Longer date on maturity of UK bonds.
Members of the Euro have been much more vulnerable

Related

Tuesday, May 10, 2011

Factors Affecting Interest Rates

Generally, central banks seek to target low inflation. The ECB target 2%. The Bank of England's inflation target is CPI 2% +/- 1. The most important factor in influencing interest rates is whether inflation is likely to deviate from this target.
  • If the Bank forecast inflation to rise above the target, they will increase interest rates to moderate economic growth and reduce the inflation rate.
  • If the Bank forecast inflation to fall below the target, they will cut interest rates to boost consumer spending and economic growth.

Temporary Inflation and Underlying Inflation

In some circumstances the headline inflation rate may rise above the target, but the Bank may choose not to increase interest rates. This is because they believe the underlying (Core) Inflation rate is still close to the target. (see: difference between CPI and Core CPI)

For example, in a period of commodity price inflation (e.g. rising oil price) or increased taxes, the Bank may view this is a temporary factor. In this case it may be more important to target economic growth and reducing unemployment - rather than the spike in headline inflation.

For example, in 2011 we have inflation rising about the target in UK, EU and US. But, this is primarily due to more temporary factors like rising oil prices, (and in UK higher taxes and devaluation). If we strip away factors that tend to be volatile, underlying inflation is lower and close to target. In 2008, inflation rose to 5% just before recession and RPI later become negative.

A key test is wage inflation. If wage inflation is much lower than the headline rate, this is an indicator that the temporary inflation is not feeding through into permanent inflationary pressures.

See: Does temporary inflation lead to permanent inflation?

Priorities in Setting Interest Rates.

The ECB have indicated that they consider targeting inflation to be the most important factor. Even if inflation is due to temporary factors, they prefer to increase interest rates to prevent any potential of inflation.

The UK has taken a more relaxed view regarding inflation. CPI inflation recently increased to 4.4% (well above upper limit of target) yet interest rates were kept at 0.5%. This indicates the Bank viewed inflation as a temporary phenomena and they were more concerned about weak economic recovery and persistently high inflation. However, this situation does prevent a dilemma for the Central bank; members of the MPC have been split on this issue.

Key Factors Influencing Inflation / Interest rates

  • Economic growth rate vs underlying trend rate. If the underlying trend rate is 2.5%, economic growth above this target is likely to cause inflationary pressure.
  • Spare capacity. A key test is the amount of spare capacity in the economy, though this can be difficult to calculate. For example, in a recession how much potential capacity is lost?
  • Wage inflation. Rising wages lead to higher costs for firms and higher spending. This is a very important factor as it can be self-reinforcing leading to a wage price spiral.
  • Unemployment. High unemployment tends to depress wage inflation and therefore keep inflationary pressure low.
  • Commodity prices. Rising commodities will tend to increase inflation. However, some commodities have a tendency to be volatile meaning it is more unreliable as a guide to underlying inflation.
  • Exchange Rate. A depreciation in the exchange rate will cause inflationary pressures. This is because imports become more expensive, and there will be greater demand for exports.
  • House prices. House prices don't directly influence the CPI. However, rising house prices causes a positive wealth effect and therefore higher consumer spending
  • Consumer confidence. Higher confidence leads to higher spending.
Related

Tuesday, April 26, 2011

Surplus on Current Account Balance of Payments

Readers Question: I can't seem to understand why a surplus on a BOP of an economy might be a problem ? The negative effects of a deficit on Current account BOP are obvious but why would economies be better off with a balance of zero compared to a surplus ?

A surplus on the current account component of the Balance of payments indicates that the country is exporting more goods and services than importing. This means they are gaining foreign currency they can use to buy foreign assets such as government bonds and invest in foreign factories.

It is not clear that a surplus on the current account is a bad thing. It has certain advantages such as being able to invest in foreign countries and build up foreign exchange reserves. It may also indicate that the country is quite competitive relative to other countries.

Countries with Large Current Account Surplus
  • Japan - 3.4% of GDP
  • China - 6.1% of GDP
  • Germany - 5.1% of GDP
  • Switzerland - 11.9% of GDP
However, a large current account surplus may indicate an unbalanced economy. For example, it may indicate the country is relying too heavily on exports and consumer spending is relatively too low. For example, during the lost decade of Japan in 90s and early 00s, they mainly had a large current account surplus.

I don't think economists would be concerned with a current account surplus per se. However, they may be concerned with policies which are generating such a big imbalance.

For example, in the case of China, one reason for large current account surplus is their decision to keep their currency undervalued. This makes their exports more competitive and imports more expensive, increasing domestic demand. However, this undervaluation of the currency is arguably contributing to inflation. China is at risk of allowing their economy to grow too quickly and cause a boom and bust.

If China allowed its currency to appreciate, this would slow down growth and reduce inflationary pressures. It would also help to reduce the size of their current account surplus.

(Of course, other countries like US would like a stronger Chinese currency as this would help their domestic industries be more competitive)

Another issue with China's large current account surplus is that they are using the foreign currency to buy a significant quantities of US and other securities. This is a mixed blessing. On the one hand, it is a contribution to financing the US debt and enables the US to keep interest rates lower.

However, if there are huge imbalances in the world economy, it could artificially keep interest rates too low in countries with current account deficits. For example, in the boom period the large inflow of funds from the East, kept interest rates on US securities low, contributing to a boom in lending. This boom in lending later proved unsustainable.

In summary, it is quite complicated. You can't say surplus bad, surplus good. However, there are definite advantages to avoiding imbalances which could create long term problems.

Related

Monday, March 14, 2011

Causes of Economic Cycles


Economic Growth has a habit of being cyclical. This is due to factors such as:
  • Importance of Confidence. When confidence evaporates in an economy it can have a knock on effect. Low consumer confidence will soon create low business confidence and there is a danger we can 'talk ourselves into recession'. Because we expect a negative growth, we save, avoid spending and this can easily cause this fall in economic growth.
  • Multiplier Effect. This states the a decline in injections causes a bigger final fall in GDP. For example, if one firm closes down, it will have knock on effects. The unemployed workers will spend less causing other firms to experience lower sales and this leads to further job losses.
  • Inflation v Economic Growth trade off. In the 60s, 70s and 80s, there appeared to be a simple trade off between growth and inflation. In a boom period, we would get high growth and high inflation. But, then politicians would worry inflation was too high. To reduce inflation, interest rates would be increased causing a fall in spending and a recession. This was certainly the case in the Lawson boom of 1980s and subsequent recession.
  • Asset Prices. Asset prices often follow the business cycle. High growth leads to rising asset prices which strengthen the boom and then when the economic cycle turns, it leads to falling asset prices which lead to a negative wealth effect and lower spending. Falling asset prices can make a recession last for a longer time.
  • Bank Lending. In a recession and period of falling asset prices, banks will face an increase in bad loans leading to financial losses. The deterioration in their balance sheets will lead to a decline in credit availability. A 'balance sheet recession' is often the most prolonged because if banks cut bank on lending (e.g. 2009 recession) then business are starved of loans and consumers find it difficult to get credit.
  • Unexpected Events. Sometimes recessions are caused by unexpected events. Certainly the oil price shock of 1973-74 was instrumental in causing a fall in spending. (Note for A Level students, it causes aggregate supply to shift to left, rather than shift in AD) The Financial crisis of 2007-08 was another example of an unexpected shock.
  • Inventory Issues. Some big ticket items are bought over a period of 10 years. If there is a mild turn down in the economy, these luxury items will not be bought. People will delay purchasing them. This contributes to bigger downturn.
Related

Monday, February 21, 2011

Output Gap and Inflation

In a recession, a fall in aggregate demand leads to a negative output gap. A negative output gap is a situation where actual GDP is less than potential GDP. This output gap is indicated by the rise in unemployment and unemployed resources.

The level of the output gap is crucial for determining inflationary pressures in the economy. A large negative output gap suggests inflation should be low. It is a situation where monetary policy will be lax (low interest rates to stimulate growth and reduce negative output gap).

A positive output gap - where growth is above the trend rate of growth, should lead to inflationary pressures.

A very simple measure of the output gap may be to assume productive capacity increases at 2.5% a year (close to the UK's average post war growth rate). Therefore, if you have a fall in GDP of 6% (like 2009), you would expect a large negative output gap, and minimal inflationary pressures.

Measuring Output Gap in Practise.

In practise it can be more difficult to measure the output gap. For example, in the aftermath of a recession, there may be much less spare capacity than you might anticipate.
  • Unemployed workers may leave the labour market and become economically inactive.
  • Firms close down leaving depressed areas and regions
  • Banks may have lost money in recession and therefore become very strict with their lending.
Also the situation may be confused by supply constraints in some industries, but spare capacity in others.
Nevertheless it is possible to make an estimate of how much spare capacity there is in the economy.

UK Output Gap and Inflation


source: HM Treasury (see bottom)

This graph shows the UK's estimated output gap (by HM Treasury) and inflation.
As you might expect there is often an inverse relationship. In the late 1980s, the Lawson boom led to a positive output gap and inflation rose to just under 10%. After the 1991/92 recession, the output gap became negative and inflation fell.

However, the 2008 rise in inflation was unrelated to the output gap. This is because the inflation was temporary and cost push inflation.

The graph doesn't show the recent rise in CPI inflation to 4%, but this rise in inflation has not been combined with a decline in the negative output graph.

The HM Treasury report suggests that many factors can affect inflation apart from the output gap.
  • Indirect taxes.
  • Effect of devaluation on import prices
  • Rise in commodity prices.
  • Inflation expectations.

Graph showing Contributions to Inflation in UK




Nevertheless, estimating the output gap helps give a broader understanding of the nature of inflation and the degree of underlying (demand pull inflation)

References

Related

Monday, February 7, 2011

Economics of High Speed Rail Links

A recent report criticised a proposed new High Speed rail link between London and Birmingham (HS2) on the grounds that:
  • Cost of building scheme (£17bn) is hard to justify given benefits would be limited to relatively small number of passengers.
  • Benefits of reducing CO2 emissions are limited.
  • There is a stronger argument for using government spending to improve existing rail infrastructure, e.g. longer trains and making better use of existing lines.
Supporters argue that demand for rail travel is continuing to grow. By 2020, projected rail use will have outstripped capacity. Investment is needed to provide more services and meet future demand. By providing extra capacity, it will relieve congestion on roads and improve the infrastructure of the UK economy. Also, by offering better quality, faster rail services, it will encourage more people to choose train. Like building new roads increased demand for car travel, building faster lines will create demand for train use.

Report calls for Rail scheme to be scrapped at Independent.

There may be a good case that investment funds may be better used on existing capacity. However, in this debate it is useful to take into account external benefits which are often ignored in public debate about the desirability of various transport schemes.

Death Rate by Mode of Transport


By comparing death rates by billion passenger KM, train travel is much safer than car use. A fatality rate of 1.9 per billion KM, compared to 0.3 billion KM for train.
  • Fatality rates of transport should be given a significant economic cost. If one form of transport is fives times safer than another, then this is a significant external benefit, which justifies government subsidy.
  • The other issue is time. A new high speed train link helps save time for both rail users and car users who benefit from lower levels of congestion.
  • The growth in train travel in the UK, is despite the fact that services are often overcrowded with a perception of being late and expensive. If train services are quicker, it will attract more people to choose train travel rather than drive.
  • Related to the issue of time, is the fact that train travel offers opportunity to work. In the age of iPads and laptops, train travel can become an opportunity to work rather than get stressed driving through the streets of Birmingham.
This doesn't mean all high speed rail networks should automatically go ahead. But, when deciding, greater mention should be made of other externalities. Train travel does justify government subsidies, but often in the UK we have made decisions on the rail network based on simple profit and loss. This has left the UK, with a transport infrastructure which increases cost on business.

Related

Sunday, January 16, 2011

Definition of Economic Depression

An economic depression involves a very significant fall in national output and corresponding period of prolonged mass unemployment.

A recession is just a period of negative economic growth. see: Definition of Recession

How To Define a Depression?

There is no single clear way to define an economic depression. It is basically a very severe form of recession. Two common ways would involve:

* A fall in GDP of 10% or more.
* A fall in GDP for over 3 years.

Other features of depression

  • Very high unemployment – over 20%
  • Deflation
  • Asset / credit contraction
Some economists say the cause is important. - Depressions are caused by unwinding credit bubbles rather than exchange rate devaluations which cause a fall in GDP and inflation

Examples of Depressions.

In the Great Depression, US GDP fell 30% between 1929 and 1933. It also fell 13% between 1937-38. With unemployment over 20% and a long period of deflation. It would meet any criteria of a depression and is inevitably used as a yardstick for measuring other depressions.

The Great Depression was also a global phenomenon. In fact many countries experienced a more severe downturn. E.g. countries like Australia and Canada which rely on raw material exports.

The biggest fall in GDP recorded was for the Soviet Union between 1990 and 1998 when recorded GDP fell 45%. However, this was due to the transition from a Command economy to a Free market economy. Part of it can also be explained by 'creative accounting' in the Communist era. Nevertheless it led to widespread economic hardship for the majority of people.

Finland experienced a drop in GDP of 11% in 1993 as it suffered from the collapse of its main trading partner the Soviet Union.

Emerging Economies have also experienced depression like periods of falls in GDP e.g. Argentina GDP fell by 19% between 1998 and 2002.

Causes of Depression

The cause of Depressions are primarily due to unwinding credit / asset bubbles and a consequent fall in money supply causing a sharp fall in demand and prices. This is different to the usual swings in the business cycle.

Are we Facing A Depression?

It is hoped we will avoid a depression because unlike the 1930s, the government is seeking to prevent a collapse in the banking system and a fall in the money supply. Also rather than trying to balance the budget, governments are pursuing expansionary fiscal policy.

However this recession is different to previous recessions which were caused by a mere tightening of monetary policy. This recession is caused by an unwinding credit / asset bubble which has the capacity to cause paralysis through deflation. For example, it is worrying that US house prices are now in their 3rd year of decline. Also rather worryingly is the fact that so far the economy appears to be not responding to standard policy measures such as tax cuts and interest rates.

However, before we hit the panic button. It is to be expected these policies will have significant time lags. It may be a severe recession but it's still a long way off being a depression (at the moment anyway)

More on definition of depression

Before the Great Depression, every downturn was called a depression. The word recession was used to avoid reviving memories of the Great Depression.

In 1978, one of Jimmy Carter’s economic advisers Alfred Khan was referring to the US facing a depression. Jimmy Carter said he didn’t like the term depression, because it created negative connotations. So Alfred Khan noted:

“We’re in danger of having the worst banana in 45 years.”

from: Economist

There is also an old saying - 'A recession is when your neighbour loses his job. A depression is when you lose your job.'

Related
  1. Causes of Great Depression
  2. essays on the great depression

Wednesday, November 17, 2010

Irish Economic Crisis

Ireland is a tragic case for a few reasons.

Boom and Bust. After joining the EU, Ireland appeared to have an economic miracle - rising investment, growth and rising living standards. At the start, much of this was based on a solid foundation. Investment helped lift Irish living standards. But, unfortunately, the positive growth led to an unsustainable boom. Banks got carried away at the prospect of continued growth. Banks relaxed their lending criteria and reduced their liquidity ratios. This led to a boom in construction and housing. When the economy turned, many investment projects looked too ambitious. Firms lost money and this led to record bank losses. The boom had turned to a bust, and the government was forced to bailout the Irish banks.

The combination of bank bailouts and economic downturn led to a dramatic collapse in tax revenues and need for more welfare payments. The Irish budget deficit shot up from 3% of GDP to over 12% of GDP (35% if you include bank bailouts)

Faced with a recession and large budget deficit. The Irish government felt they had no choice but to tackle the deficit through higher taxes and spending cuts. Remarkably the Irish electorate largely accepted these stern measures such as public sector wage cuts of 5%. Yet, these emergency measures exacerbated the loss in confidence and led to lower spending and investment. The consequence of the austerity measures was that the Irish economy suffered a double dip downturn.

Ironically, the harsh austerity measures failed to reassure nervous European bond investors. Bond yields on Irish bonds have continued to grow to crippling levels. The result is that Ireland is facing the need for a bailout and more austerity measures. This is the last thing the economy wants, but, given constraints of being a Euro member there is little alternative.

Lack of Alternatives

The Irish largely see EU membership as an unqualified success and by implication, membership of the Euro a good thing. Unfortunately, this crisis has shown the limitations of being a member of a single currency and common monetary policy.

Usually, a country in the situation of Ireland which needed to cut budget deficit in times of recession, would at least have monetary policy to offset some of the decline in spending and investment. For example, they could have followed UK and pursued quantitative easing. This would have increased demand and lowered their exchange rate. This depreciation would have helped domestic firms exporting.

But, Ireland doesn't have this option. Membership of the Euro means you have to follow the unpalatable options but, there isn't much else you can do to help.


The situation looks grim. There may be some crumbs of comfort. Recent figures on investment spending looked promising. The Irish crisis is ironically going to weaken the Euro. But, it may not be enough to pull the Irish economy back to growth without much economic pain.

There is also a sense of unfairness. The banks which created a large part of problem through irresponsible lending have been rescued unconditionally by government. But, it is ordinary people who are experiencing pain of wage freezes, job losses and spending cuts.

If it was as simple as leaving the Euro, I would tell them to do it tomorrow. But, leaving the Euro is not that simple. (why difficult to leave Euro)

The Irish economy shows

  • The dangers of allowing a boom and bust in bank lending
  • the difficult of cutting budget deficit in recession. - Measures tend to be self-defeating unless you have some very powerful antidote.
  • The difficulty of adopting a common monetary policy for an area as diverse as the Eurozone.
The Irish is crisis is particularly tragic because it didn't need to be like this. With better regulation and monitoring of the boom, lending could have been curtailed in boom. If they weren't in the Euro, they would have had more room for manoeuvre to deal with the situation they currently face.

Related

Friday, November 5, 2010

Why The Fed is Buying US Bonds

The Federal Reserve have announced a plan to buy $75 billion of US Treasury bills each month up to a total of $600bn by end of 2011.

The Federal Reserve are worried about the US recovery. Though, the US has officially left recession, there are signs that the economy remains depressed and below full capacity.
  • Unemployment is stubbornly high (just below 10%)
  • House prices continue to be weak.
  • Low income growth
  • Still continued signs of disinflation (Falling inflation rate, below US target)
The Federal Reserve have indicated the desirability of fiscal stimulus (e.g. public works spending) however, given the state of US congress, this is unlikely to materialise. With short term interest rates close to 0%, conventional monetary policy doesn't offer many options.
Therefore, the Fed are proposing to buy more long term dated government bonds through the policy of quantitative easing (electronically creating money)

Impact of Buying US Treasuries

  • Buying long term bonds will drive down interest rates on government bonds. This fall in bonds should also help decrease interest rates on corporate bonds.
  • Lower interest rates on corporate bonds should help boost investment and spending, leading to stronger economic growth.
  • Increased Money supply should help combat the deflationary pressures in the economy. By buying treasury bonds off banks, they in turn have more liquidity to lend to business.
  • Increasing money supply and purchase of US treasuries weakens the US dollar. A weaker dollar makes US exports more competitive helping boost exports and reduce imports.

Potential Problems of Policy

  • Some economists argue the round of Quantitative easing is too small as a % of the economy. Without changing public expectations of inflation, the US recovery may continue to be too slow.
  • Monetary Policy is not a magic tool. Reducing interest rates on government and corporate bonds may be insufficient to induce lending, when confidence and effective demand is not there.
  • A more effective combination would be fiscal policy and quantitative easing. Higher government spending on public works scheme would help inject demand into economy and give firms a greater incentive to borrow and invest.

On the other hand, other economists worry about policy from opposite point of view. For example,
  • By weakening the dollar, the US risks alienating investors in US assets. People could fear the dollar is not reliable as a safe investment like in the past.
  • By increasing money supply and weakening the dollar, there is the prospect of increasing long term inflationary pressure.
  • By artificially reducing interest rates, the Fed may be encouraging an increase in unsustainable borrowing and cause a misallocation of resources in the economy. It may lead to an asset bubble.
Related